"That thread confuses me. I must say I can't remember seeing a single review - at least not in the last year - that says Season 8 is like season 1 of BtVS; there might have been the odd one that I've missed, but "almost all"? Where? Why make up criticisms only to refute them?"

Because the person who started the thread got her facts slightly wrong. Someone said something along those lines, but not the way she was putting it.

I'm glad that you didn't remember anyone saying that either. I thought I was going mad myself. *g*


There's a lot of 'born again' season 8 folk on there aren't there. :0