Hey, Roby - I didn't know you have an LJ! (I feel a bit foolish about my recommendation to create an LJ account, lol!)

I often disagree with AoQ too - but I find fascinating the non-shipper angle on the show. Sometimes I think we're really become myopic and sometimes can't see the bigger picture.
I love our discussions on CDS, in safe shipper heaven, but at the same time I love debates with other shippers on SMGfan - these debates help to delve into the show more deeply.
And, of course, an opinion of a casual viever sometimes may be very unexpected!
By far, the most shocking AoQ's rating is "excellent" for "Dead Man's party".